Well, it's sad but sometimes you have to look further for a sweet happy ending... and for further, today, I don't mean "further down" but far away from my blog.... (Please promise to come back and cheer me up!).
Before making the Nectarine Upside Down-Chiffon Cake chosen by our group "Tuesdays with Dorie - Baking with Julia", I watched Mrs Mary Bargin's video on "how to make it". I really did not find it difficult (time consuming but not difficult) and her explanations were really good...
...BUT,
...The first cake (picture on the left) that came out of my oven looked great, almost like Mary's, if not for a small and "irrelevant" difference: the center of mine didn't bake properly and was runny!! ...what I unfortunately discovered only after cutting it (How on earth have I missed thaaat detail!!).I was on my way to the waste bin (imagine my mood!), and:
"Wait! Look! The edges are well baked! Give it a chance!"
...One sad look full of hope, one bite full of expectations: Nothing! I didn't enjoy it! I-just-did-not-like-it!!
I didn't like the topping made of so much butter and dark brown sugar: greasy, too sweet (can you believe me saying that!) and with an extremely strong taste of dark brown sugar: really not my piece of cake! And the crumble between the layers of the chiffon cake was much too much!
Please note: dark and light brown sugar appeared in my life less than 1 year ago, when I started the exciting "Christmas Cookie Club Project", after reading and loving A. Pearlman's novel "The Christmas Cookie Club", based on profound friendships and cookies (that's all we need, isn't it!)
These sugars are hardly available in Switzerland and are 6 times more expensive than white sugar. I do like them. I do use them in cookies, cakes, candies but not as a topping - this kind of topping.
Now, if you have been following me for a while, you know that I don't admit defeat (especially in the kitchen! especially that easily!).
So, changing a few steps, I rolled up my sleeves and remade the cake (picture on the right):
Butter: I've brushed the pan with a small portion of softened butter.
Dark brown sugar: I've reduced to 3/4 cup, making a mix of 1/4 dark brown sugar 2/4 light brown sugar.
Crumble: I've used about 1/4 of it (and kept the rest on the fridge - maybe I could mix it to my homemade granola, for once)
Nectarine: I've diced them. Not that I did not like the previous decoration, but I wanted to try a different "design".
Vanilla: I've added some homemade vanilla extract to the cake batter.
Pan: I did not have a 10 inch pan (only a 9 inch) and poured the extra batter in a second one, covering the batter with some crumble (since I still had so much left).
So, changing a few steps, I rolled up my sleeves and remade the cake (picture on the right):
Butter: I've brushed the pan with a small portion of softened butter.
Dark brown sugar: I've reduced to 3/4 cup, making a mix of 1/4 dark brown sugar 2/4 light brown sugar.
Crumble: I've used about 1/4 of it (and kept the rest on the fridge - maybe I could mix it to my homemade granola, for once)
Nectarine: I've diced them. Not that I did not like the previous decoration, but I wanted to try a different "design".
Vanilla: I've added some homemade vanilla extract to the cake batter.
Pan: I did not have a 10 inch pan (only a 9 inch) and poured the extra batter in a second one, covering the batter with some crumble (since I still had so much left).
Drumroll... :
The center was solid, but still far away from the "spongy" it should be.
Chiffon cake: the taste was good. I really enjoyed the vanilla touch! But I personally find that 1/2 cup of oil is a lot.
Topping: unfortunately still to sweet
The end result:
Almost with tears in my eyes I have to admit that this cake is just not for me... Me rejecting a cake???! How come?!!!!
The center was solid, but still far away from the "spongy" it should be.
Chiffon cake: the taste was good. I really enjoyed the vanilla touch! But I personally find that 1/2 cup of oil is a lot.
Topping: unfortunately still to sweet
The end result:
Almost with tears in my eyes I have to admit that this cake is just not for me... Me rejecting a cake???! How come?!!!!
Please do visit Marlise of The Double Trouble Kitchen
and Susan of The Little French Bakery. On their blog you'll find two marvellous cakes waiting for you! Please, just forget what your read in my blog (I mean, after commenting :-) ) and ...be happy...happily baking! Hope you'll love it more than I did.
Chiedo scusa a tutti i lettori di lingua italiana per non aver tradotto questa ricetta e vi prego di contattarmi, se desiderate riceverla. Sappiate però che nonostante l'abbia preparate due volte - non mi è piaciuta (troppo dolce) e non è mai cotta al punto giusto. Ho rinunciato a fare un terzo tentativo.
Guardate comunque il video, è molto interessante.
Guardate comunque il video, è molto interessante.
Dove acquistare i libri. You can buy
the books from:

I'm sorry that it didn't turn out for you :(
ReplyDeleteThank you Sara. Your idea to use Plums instead of Nectarine sounds delicious!
DeleteOh, phooey. What a disappointment!! I know I ended up baking mine much longer than the recipe stated...but if you didn't like it, you didn't like it! On to the wheat bread :)
ReplyDeleteThank you Lizzy. Your chiffon cake is beautiful and I was so pleased that you loved it (maybe I'm the only "black sheep" of the group).
DeleteOn to the wheat bread...yesssss! I love it!
Goodness you tried and tried. I wonder if it was the substitutions that caused the problems. Well, you have so many other wonderful cake recipes that this one should not hold you back from making more cakes. Thanks for your comments on my blog.
ReplyDeleteHi Marlise,
DeleteThe first time I made no substitution ...Must be what is called "bad chemistry"!
Thank you for visiting and commenting.
What a relief to know that I'm not the only one who didn't like the flavor. I expected something light and summery. You know, with words like "nectarine" and "chiffon"... well, I was unprepared for greasy dark brown sugar. But forged ahead with an open mind. I wanted to like it. I really did. Thanks for the validation.
ReplyDeleteThank you Margaret.
DeleteYou made such a beatiful pecan pie!
Reading the recipe and noting the amounts of oil+butter and sugar, I decided to reduce them. Since I used grapes that were sweeter than nectarines, the end result was quite satisfactory. I have posted the adjustments on my blog. Good job for persevering and baking the cake twice!
ReplyDeleteThank you ovenchaos. I've never baked with fresh grapes. Your cake looks wonderfully yummy!
DeleteLuckily there are plenty of cakes to make--it's ok if you don't like it! I don't think the cake needed the streusel at all. But I was proud of myself for making a cake out of my comfort zone.
ReplyDeleteGood job, great photos!
Thank you Cindy.
DeleteNB: I love the pillow you just posted about: it's fantastic!
I am sorry this cake was not for you! I am also sorry you had issues making it!
ReplyDeleteThank you Im at home Baking.
DeleteYours plum cake is beautiful. Hope the fruit price is not always like that in Japan!
At least you tried. Kudos for that!
ReplyDeleteHi Yummychunklet, hope you are feeling better.
DeleteWish you all the best with your ankle.
Isn't it fun seeing the very same recipe baked around the world and how close we are when we unveil the cake? I have a love-hate relationship with this one, but ended up happy when eating it!! Fun baking with the group! Blessings, Catherine
ReplyDeletehttp://praycookblog.com/2012/09/twd-bwj-nectarine-upside-down-chiffon-cake/
Thank you Catherine.
DeleteI loved making it ... I didn't love eating it.
The fun to bake all together makes me forget my defeats.
I baked my cake about 20 minutes longer than was called for. So sorry this one didn’t work out for you! Such a disappointment!
ReplyDeleteThank you Kathy.
DeleteWe thought it was a little too sweet as well, but we liked it. Hopefully the next recipe will be more to your liking!
ReplyDeleteThank you Loaves and Stitches
DeleteSorry this cake didn't work for you. I think you'll love the wheat loaves, though. We devoured them!
ReplyDeleteThank you Teresa. I'm pleased you loved it that much.
DeleteWheat loves: yessss! I love it! So far my most baked recipe from the book.
Carola, too bad that this cake did not really turn out to be a success for you but you have so many wonderful cakes in your past and future that at the end of the day this one recipe will not make so much of a difference!
ReplyDeleteLiebe Grüsse, Andrea
Thank you Andrea.
DeleteSorry that this cake was not all that you hoped it to be. I am impressed that you gave it two tries! Like Andrea said - you make so many great desserts that this will be just a mere memory in the near future!
ReplyDeleteThank you Cher for your kind words.
DeleteI gave it a second try, because I so seldom (but really seldom)
do not like a cake.
I thought, I may have messed something up.
I have just found your blog, and love that it is bilingual, so I have bookmarked it to get more recipes in italian!
ReplyDeleteWELCOME and thank you Zeeona.
DeletePlease join the blog and / or subscribe to it if you wish to receive an email, each time I post a recipe.
Nice to have you here. All the best
As beautiful as this cake was, it was not a hit for me either. I'm looking forward to the whole wheat loaves. I read that you made 7 loaves!! Must be good. Keeping my fingers crossed! :)
ReplyDeleteWhat a pity, Cathleen! Your cake was so beautiful.
DeleteHope you'll love the bread at least 1/2 of what I love it :-)